Kommentare

Kommentar von 29050

Design for this meta is dropped by Coilskar Sirens in Shadowmoon Valley.

New in patch 2.3, this design is intended to balance the change to Relentless Earthstorm Diamond as of 2.2 - that change being that the 3% increased critical damage no longer applies to spells.

Kommentar von 45010

The requirement isn't as bad as people make this out to be. In fact, for a destruction warlock the requirement is actually pretty nice. With no +hit talents at all, we have to hit max cap somehow. And what you can't get in gear, get in gems. Even T5 and loot of similar level doesn't boast very big +hit, it's mostly all +dmg/+crit. So to make up the difference you stack pure hit (yellow) or hit/dmg hybrid (yellow/red) gems. You have very little room to sneak a blue gem in unless you can exceed the hit cap and have a socket set bonus that requires a blue gem.

Even though the Mystical Skyfire meta provides more benefit for destruction than the Swift Skyfire meta, the fact you need to have more blue than yellow gems for the effect makes hampers the actual usefulness of the gem. This gem does not share this problem. DPS casters can use this effect while still maintaining a normal gem structure.

Kommentar von 93564

Can someone post the math analysis of this gem - i.e. the amount of dmg it'll do compared to an optimal half cast proc (on a fireball or such) per minute.

Just wanna get the lowdown before regemming everything again.

Kommentar von edeen

Math time!

First off we presume that Fireball regular hit is 2000, crit 3000, and casting time 3.0, and you're a bot, meaning you don't miss a single second! You also have 25% spellcrit. (All fictional, just to show the difference).

With the Mystical Skyfire Diamond (5% proccrate) you cast 100 fireballs.

25% of them crit.

(2000x75) + (3000x25) = 150 000 + 75 000 = 225 000 total damage.(We aren't counting clearcasting proccs)

Casting time:

3x100= 300 seconds total casting time (without meta gem!)

Now, with the procrate, 5% of these 100 spells will have halfed casting time, meaning the calculation changes to:

(3x95)+(1.5x5) = 285+7.5 = 292.5 seconds

DPS:

225 000 / 292.5 = 769.2307... DPS ~ 769 DPS

Now, with this meta gem (Chaotic):

12 Spell Critical rating = 0.7 %

So, yet again, you cast 100 fireballs, 2000 regular damage, 3090 critical damage (+3%) and your spellcrit is 25.7 (Making this a round number for the calcultion, to 26% spellcrit).

Damage:

(2000x74)+(3090x26) = 148000 + 80340 = 228 340 damage

Casting time:

3x100 = 300 seconds

DPS:

228 340 / 300 = 761.133333... ~ 761 DPS

So, from this you get that the Mystical Skyfire Diamond gives you 6 more DPS.

:D

Now I hope this is correct :p

Kommentar von 93746

Any idea on if this will affect healing crits too? The tooltip says 3% to damage (melee damage if you read the buff description) but it may only say that for brevity.

Kommentar von 19962

Also remember:

1.) Mystical Skyfire is getting a cooldown, I haven't tested it - but I assume it's going to inhibit back to back procs.

2.) The gem reqs are incredibly less restrictive on this gem. I wear about 8-10 gems normally - having only two blues, instead of 6, is going to be wonderful.

Kommentar von 93564

Ok, new question for those that can do the math so well.

They are sinking the MSD, so that's out. is it time to retire the meta gem helm and go back to the spellstrike helm?

given the proc from the spellstrike set, whats the analysis between CSD/MSD/spellstrike set. which one is best?

Im thinking spellstrike set is best to go back to with the 92dmg proc, but just wanna make sure.

also is there a place for mages like shadowpriest.com where the gear is ranked by mathmatical analysis for each selection?

sorry for the long post

Kommentar von 93564

anyone?

is spellstrike hood gonna be better than collar of the aldor with CSD or MSD after 2.3?

Kommentar von Hokulea

Has anyone tested if you can have more than 2 blue gems? Since it's the word exactly vs. the words at least.

Kommentar von nickolina

Bare in mind that it's only 3% of your 'critial damage'.. so work out typically what your total crit damage is.. For example a typical Arcane Missile crit for me is 1700.. 700 damage is the crit. 3% of 700 21 damage.. If i'm lucky that's 42 additional damage per arcane missile.

Ask yourself this. Over a period of 45 seconds.. how many spells you can cast, and how much 'critical' damage you will generate over that time. Now work out how much extra dps you would get from the MSD and compare.

Kommentar von 93564

think that CSD will be better than spellstrike proc?

Kommentar von 88563

If you think this Item does not raise your DPS substantially like nickolina does, calculate this: This Item will raise you overall DPS by approx 0.03x your crit rate. If you have a crit rate of 30% (and if you are3 in a raid and are buffed you better have 30%) this is about a 1% dmg increase, and this is not calculating in the 12 Crit. And this 1% is alot for one gem...

Kommentar von 93564

quick question, would it be worth trading out the spellstrike set bonus (+92 dmg proc) for this (CSD) with the collar of the aldor?

Kommentar von AlphaQ

Several reasons why Chaotic Skyfire Diamond will be superior to Mystical Skyfire Diamond for mages.

1) CSD gives you more freedom in gemming. You have the flexibility to gem with hit if you're not hit capped or you can go straight damage. MSD hinders your optimal gemming by forcing you to have more blues than yellows.

2) With all the new haste gear coming out from BT and ZA, CSD will scale with the haste while MSD will not.

3) With MSD nerfed to have an internal cooldown it is very poor with Arcane. MSD is also not very great for Frost and if your guild is pushing for Illidan then CSD will be the much better choice.

Kommentar von 99247

In any case this gem will be very useful to destruction spec locks. Perhaps moreso than any other class or spec.

Kommentar von 4644

Yes it is THE BEST meta for Destro lock hands down!

I did some numbers the other day and something people need to understand about this gem. It gets double benefit from crit modifying talents (Ruin, Ice Shards, etc) so if you have 100% increased crit dmg from talents the meta will be doubled in value:

No talents: 150%(crit)*1.03%=154.5% (4.5% gain in crit dmg)
With Ruin: 200%*1.03%=206% (6% gain in crit dmg) in other words a Destro / Frost mage are going to get double the benefit from the meta and because both frost and shadow destro are built with high crit the meta will be in use very often.

Here is a quick theorycraft:

6000crit = 6360meta crit
6500crit = 6890meta crit
7000crit = 7420meta crit
7500crit = 7950meta crit
8000crit = 8480meta crit
10000crit = 10600meta crit

Taking me for example (T5 lock) critting for 7k prepatch is common in a raid so lets continue to see how much dmg is gained overall from this meta.

Lets assume we cast 100 shadowbolts and we have a 33% (for easy math) crit rate with 7000 crits being average crit dmg.

1/3rd of the shadowbolts will crit or 33 (1 shadowbolt will miss assuming 16% hit) crit shadowbolts:

33(7000)=231000 unmeta'd crit dmg
33(7000*1.06)= 244860 meta'd crit dmg

We gained 13860 damage over not having a meta.

Overall with the positive scaling (unlike MSD) and the ability of the meta to always be active makes this well worth gemming for.

Kommentar von 99689

I don't know if it was because half the server was trying to farm these today or what but got mine in about 20 mins about an hour after the patch came out.

pvtpile
Alliance-Destromath

Kommentar von BlueStorm

This meta is a godsend for me as I use lotsa orange gems for +spellhit and surely won't be able to match the requirements of MSD.

The +3% critical damage is especially good as it applies on the base critical damage instead of total critical damage. Testing on dr. boom with total of more than 100 bolt casts, Recap puts my critical damage is 2.09x normal damage on average (with ruin talent obviousl). Without the meta, the crit is only 2x.

Seems that the bonus is applied on the extra 50% dmg (crit untalented) making it 54.5%. With ruin, the bonus from crit damage becomes 109%, thus 209% crit instead of 200%

Kommentar von 16217

I highly doubt "3% Increased Critical Damage" Affects spell crits at the moment. For one, where is the "spell" in the name? Second if you look at the description of "3% Increased Critical Damage" it clearly states, Apply Aura: Mod Crit Damage Bonus (Melee) (895).
GG Blizzard?

Kommentar von 104210

Can anyone confirm they are changing the requirement for this in 2.3.2? Right now with the "exactly" 2 blue gems requirement I can't fit this into my current gear.

Kommentar von 11771

http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=2856204497&postId=29491234685&sid=1

Blue says here that next patch and next patch is 2.3.2. So that means in like ~2 weeks from now on.

Kommentar von Cantras

The link posted is no longer active, and I can't find this mentioned in ptr notes or wowhead or whatever. Does anyone have any solid information about it being changed to "at least two" instead of "exactly"?

Also, I would presume this means that, after I've got my two blues, my gem options are red orange yellow? That is, will adding a purple or green gem disqualify it?

Kommentar von 120888

This is Actualy a transmute item it can be quita money earn to sell these every 23hrs (CoolDown) it can worth quite a lot for mats it takes about 60g-90g and it can be sold for 100-150 g

Kommentar von 122865

Does the requirement "at least 2 blue gems" require 2 actual blue gems or will purple/green ones count?

Kommentar von 47954

ok i was reading through the 209% with ruin comments, this is a 4.5% dmg increase. if this is the case, this gem is pretty sweet for 0/40/21 or 0/21/40 locks. let me run some numbers by you in a raid situation, without the gem. now lets say you have the following buffs and debuffs on your target:
200% crit dmg
20% imp shadowbolt
15% sacrificed succy
10% curse of shadow
10% shadow dmg from shadow priest
5% all spell dmg from shadow priest
10% dmg increase from bm hunter proc

200%*1.2*1.15*1.1*1.1*1.05*1.1 = 385.72% dmg increase

now if this gem truely increases your base crit dmg to 209% this is what we get:
209%*1.2*1.15*1.1*1.1*1.05*1.1 = 403.08% dmg increase

notice this is also a 4.5% dmg increase, (385.72/403.08) = 1.045

so in this "perfect" situation lets say your shadowbolt would crit for 8000, the gem would increase that to 8360, doesnt sound like much but if you are a destro lock with high crit, it really adds up.

Kommentar von 28374

For Warlocks your crit is 209% (tested) with this gem and the math that blizzard uses to determine this is as follows...

With Ruin your Critical strike Damage bonus is 100% more than what your critical strikes are without it, so you take the Damage increase from a critical strike and multiply it by 2. Now the gem says 3% increased critical damage, which doesn't mean +3% bonus damage it means 3% more total, so you take the damage a critical strike would do and then add 3% to that value.

Thus

150% x 1.03 = 154.5% (Total damage from a crit with this gem but without ruin)
154.5% - 100% = 54.5% (Bonus damage from a crit with this gem but without ruin)
54.5% X 2 = 109% (bonus damage with ruin and gem)
100%+109% = 209% (damage done by a critical with gem and ruin)

Kommentar von 44125

it just says damage. does this also apply to heal crits?

Kommentar von 131626

If this Gem worked on crit heals it would probably be the best healing gem out there for a pally.

Kommentar von 56896

This gem is also the equivalent of ignoring around 60 resilience (crit damage reduction). After the nerf to MSD, this gem seems more of a better option than before for PvP.

Kommentar von veno3

Ignores approx. 60 resilience.

Now that MSD is complete trash i'd say this is the one worth getting.

Kommentar von Vifor

If wowhead link for that 3% Increased Critical Damage isn't totaly wrong, seems this aply to melee dmg. Wich make it wortless for most classes and specs except maybe retribution palas.

Kommentar von unckle

theory... ;)

a melee has white dmg = 100 damage
crit = 30%
crit's hit for 200 damage

the melee hits a target with 10% crit reduction ( a lot of ressi.. )

in 100 hits you get : 80 normal hits + 20 crit hits = 12000 dmg ( 8000 + 4000 )

if the melee has 3% more dmg on crit

in 100 hits he gets 80 normal hits + 20 crit hits = ( 8000 + 4000x(1 +0.03) ) = 12120dmg

you gain 120 = 0,6 x " one critical hit " = "0,6% more crit chance" ...wich is something like...15 resilience " negation "

i hope i'm not wrong . . . ofc i will erase this if i am wrong.. ;)

Kommentar von 30280

So what's the difference between "+14 Spell Crit Rating" http://www.wowhead.com/?item=25890 and "+12 Spell Critical" http://www.wowhead.com/?item=34220 ???

Seems like the same thing, but is it really? If it is, I'd prefer the +3% increased crit damage over the 1% reflect.

Posted to both items comments sections.

Kommentar von 204709

as of the 3.0 consolidation of melee and spell crit, this gem is better than Relentless Earthstorm Diamond for Retadins and Arms/Fury warriors, not only because they get slightly more crit from rating than agi, but also because the gem requirements for Chaotic are much easier to accomplish than Relentless. Other physical dps classes would probably still be better off with relentless, though the difficulty in gem requirements makes this debatable.

Kommentar von superhumanjesse

is this the best dps meta for warriors?

Kommentar von 310459

As of now:

Chaotic Skyfire Diamond
+12 Critical Strike Rating and 3% Increased Critical Damage
Requires more Blue gems than Blue gems
Item Level 70
"Only fits in a meta gem slot."
Sell Price: 3g

Kommentar von CyanideCloud

Blizzard really messed up with that one... D:

Kommentar von mailou

not working for now in 4.0.3a

Kommentar von 446207

what is this I don't even

Kommentar von dstruct2k

Explain this "Requires more Blue gems than Blue gems" bit... Wouldn't that always be both true and false?

Kommentar von 310077

The tooltip accurately describes how this meta works, or fails to work, in game. I tested every possible condition, and this meta-gem will not activate.

3D-Ansicht Links

Kurzübersicht

Screenshots

Videos

Wechselhafter Himmelsfeuerdiamant

Gegenstandsstufe 27
+3 kritischer Trefferwert und um 3% erhöhter kritischer Effekt

"Passt nur in einen Sockel der Kategorie Meta."

Maximaler Stapel: 200

Verkaufspreis: 62 50

Wechselhafter Himmelsfeuerdiamant

Weiteres

Beitragen