Kurzübersicht

Screenshots

Videos

Kommentare

Kommentar von Vallani

Marcia Balzer verkauft im neuen Dalaran neben dem Brunnen folgende Köder welche das angeln der notwendigen Münzen für den Erfolg Der Wunschentferner erleichtern:

Hypermagnetischer Köder
Klecks echt klebrigen Leims
Mikrovortexgenerator
Wunschkristall
Alchemistisches Haftmittel
Winzig kleines Greifgerät
Seestern mit Faden
für je 4g63s

Die Köder sind einzigartig tragbar und halten je 2 Minuten.

(Die Münzen sind auch ohne die Köder fangbar!)

Jeder Köder erhöht die Fangchance für unterschiedliche Münzen. Es empfiehlt sich also alle Köder zu nutzen.
(Es ist jedoch möglich alle Münzen mit einem Köder zu bekommen.)

Kommentar von Froxx

Ich habe erst damit angefangen jeden Köder 1x zu nutzen, und wieder von vorne anzufangen, sobald ich mit jedem durch war.
Das Ganze habe ich solange gemacht, bis ich bei rund 10 verbleibenden Münzen war. Hat mich 2 Durchgänge mit jedem Köder gekostet.
Ab dem Moment habe ich die einzelnen Wowhead Links zu den Items aufgemacht, und geschaut, welche Köder dort empfohlen werden.
So habe ich mich dann vorangearbeitet, bis ich alle Münzen hatte.

Meine letzte Münze Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara habe ich nach 2h 32min und 830 Versuchen bekommen, während ich mit Klecks echt klebrigen Leims gebufft war (was aber natürlich nichts heißen muss).

Falls Wowhead ihn zulässt, findet ihr einen detaillierten Screenshot meiner Fishing Buddy (ein Angel Addon) Statistiken in den Screenshots.

Kommentare

Kommentar von Feliciamarie

NOooooooo not again D: I thought those days were behind me lol

Kommentar von Tykes

Please, Blizzard, give us anything but a coin to flip at the end of this achievement!

Kommentar von Nynaeve

Legion Dalaran's version of the meta-achievement: Der Münzmeister.
It's possible Blizzard may yet split this one up, as the original was:

Wer den Pfennig nicht ehrt, ist des Talers nicht wert
Silberregen
Da is' Gold in dem Brunnen!

There may be help: Klecks echt klebrigen Leims, Auriphage Sardine, Wunschkristall.
If so, this may be so we don't have to miss out on the sell value of coins, as you did if you wanted the buff for the previous achievement, from throwing the gold coins back in for the old fountain, e.g. Anduin Wrynns Goldmünze.

As with the coins from the previous achievement, these coins can be sold to a vendor.

This will likely take some time. Prepare with lures, snacks, and, at the very least, some music.

Seems ominous, perhaps even fortelling: Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara

Kommentar von Romire

*Sigh*

/cast line

Kommentar von SoCalWoWGal

Marcia Balzer in Dalaran - Broken Isles sells these items that can be useful for completing the Der Wunschentferner achievement.

Hypermagnetischer Köder
Auriphage Sardine
Klecks echt klebrigen Leims
Mikrovortexgenerator
Wunschkristall
Alchemistisches Haftmittel
Seestern mit Faden
Winzig kleines Greifgerät

EDIT: Updated Information(##RESPBREAK##)2##DELIM##Sas148##DELIM##

Kommentar von bitehattori

I put on my rod and fishing hat.

Kommentar von 503532

Ahhhhh, my wish to torment you by making Dalaran fishing once again viable, has succeeded!

Now, the only way you can remove my curse is to fish up my wish coin from the fountain of Dalaran. . . And that may require you to do a lot of fishing. . .

Muahahahahaha! A Perfect Paradox!

—

Kommentar von ZeeAUS

You'll need ~~this achievement - Der Wunschentferner, and also~~ Dicke Fische which is to fish up all the rare legion fish in order to unlock the Fishing Artifact - Underweight Angler.
Plus a Fishing Skill of 800 - which by the time you complete either of these two achievements you'll probably already have.

The need for Der Wunschentferner for the artifact was removed during beta - so now you'll fish up all the coins just for the love of it and your 10 points.

Kommentar von PvtDeth

I was so sad when I fished the last coin out of the fountain in Wrath. Now my life finally has purpose again.

.
.
.
.

Hooray

Kommentar von Tenjen

Great. Lets see what new damage the fountain has wrecked upon peoples lives when they use it for wishes.

No seriously, reading peoples wishes and realizing how it had been twisted around was the best part of the coins. There are still old coins proving to be ironic due to events after wotlk in cata, MoP and WoD.

Kommentar von jjanchan

Der Wunschentferner is the new version of the Dalaran coin achievements from Wrath of the Lich King (Wer den Pfennig nicht ehrt, ist des Talers nicht wert, Silberregen, Da is' Gold in dem Brunnen!). A total of 56 different coins/baubles must be fished up for Der Wunschentferner.

A few baits will help you complete this task. All of the various special baits are:

These baits can be purchased from Marcia Balzer, located in the Eventide at (by the Dalaran Fountain). They cost each (discounted to a minimum of at Exalted reputation with the Kirin Tor).

Some other notes:

Each coin, apart from having some fun flavour text, can be vendored for anywhere from 1 copper to 5 gold.
Each of the above listed baits grants a 2-minute fishing buff.
Coins can be fished up without any bait applied.

The catch rate for coins with a bait applied appears to be higher than without.*
The baits increase the chances of specific coins being caught.

Even with bait, the chance of fishing up a coin is between 25 and 40% (not guaranteed).
In order to fish from the fountain and catch coins, your Fishing skill does not have to be very high (coins were fished up with a skill as low as 50).
Almost every cast, whether you net a coin or not, will give you trash fish Großer Brunnengoldfisch. These stack to 20 and can fill up your bags fairly quickly!

*Based on a small sample size of ~500 casts.(##RESPBREAK##)2##DELIM##Wowhead##DELIM##

Kommentar von TamiayTheGnome

If you have low fishing skill, I imagine all you will be is "The Fish Remover".

Kommentar von deviouskat89

I want to start a list of coins I fish up with different bait, to help start determining what bait equates to what coins. I suppose you can fish up any coin with any bait, since these just up the chance, but hopefully with more data we can start pinpointing increased % chance.

Here's my first round of using each bait once (2 min each), starting at 730 skill:

Hypermagnetic Lure - Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin, Li Li's Coin, God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Auriphagic Sardine - Elothir's Golden Leaf
Glob of Really Sticky Glue - Illidan's Coin, Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin
Micro-Vortex Generator - Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin, First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin, Koda's Sigil
Wish Crystal - Lunara's Coin, Vydhar's Wooden Nickel
Alchemical Bonding Agent - The Candleking's Candlecoin, Li Li's Coin, First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin, King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin x2, Queen Azshara's Royal Seal
Starfish on a String - Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin and Izal Whitemoon's Coin (same cast!), Koda's Sigil, Yowlon's Mark, Kayn Sunfury's Coin, Torok Bloodtotem's Coin
Tiny Little Grabbing Apparatus - Penelope's Heathrow's Allowance, Yowlon's Mark

Very few duplicates for the first round! I'll continue to edit this comment as I make more attempts.

Kommentar von Burbul1s

So since, i believe, i`m first crazy person who did this, i thought i`ll share the experience.
Took me 5h 35 min and 1250 casts. I wont bother how much other stuff i fished.
Every single cast gave me Großer Brunnengoldfisch they stack at 20 so they fill up much space.
You can fish up only those fishes and coins, there can be 2 coins in single cast.
Senegos` Ancient Coin was last one at took me ~1h.
Used random fishing buff from Marcia Chase merchant.
Personally this took me a lot more time than WOTLK fishing achivs. Did them in ~3h30min.
Starting skill 617, got 800 after about 4h. Using only Jeweled Fishing Pole.

Kommentar von Scwraith

Here's my Auction house prices?
Coins worth
1 copper = 25g min 50g B/O
1 Silver = 50g min 100g B/O
1 Gold = 100G min 150g B/O
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal seems to drop the most, but is worth most at 5g. So worth the same as 1 Copper coins at 25g - 50g.
Are those unreasonable prices?

Kommentar von Ydris

Was delighted to fish up the Giant Sewer Rat from the fountain, I had no idea it could drop from there. So there is a chance for that, too, as a side bonus to working on this achieve.

Kommentar von clarky1976

5 hours slit over one evening and the next morning and still stuck on 3 coins
- Prince Farondis' Royal Seal
- Senegos' Ancient Coin
- Murky's Coin

the drop rate on these 3 are terrible! and tbh the cost of the lures at 5g.40s seem a bit steep for A 2 minute buff.
the only good thing is that i have maxed my fishing skill lol

Kommentar von Jinxxie

So here is some quick info that might be helpful to others.

My fishing skill was under 100 and I was catching a lot of coins in the begining. Therefor I believe it does not matter what your fishing skill is nor does it effect the chance of how often you fish up coins.

It took me almost 6 hours to fish up every coin. after 4 hours in I had everything except for 2 coins and for 2 hours straight I did not catch either of them and it was pain. The coins were Vydhars Holzgroschen and Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin.

Fun fact: Once I fished up Vydhars Holzgroschen. It didnt take long till I had 3 of them...

Within the last hour I started using coin bait that I bought from Marcia Balzer and I did notice some huge difference besides fishing up coins like crazy.

With the bait you are able to fish up 2 coins at a time. The chances are uncommon/rare and I even had it that I fished up 2 coins three times in row. I never fished up two coins within those 5 hours I fished raw.

Funfact: In the end I had 1270 Großer Brunnengoldfisch

Hopefully I got all interesting info in this post. Happy fishing!

Kommentar von Kahzria

It took me 943 casts, four and a half hours, 42 of the special lures sold by Marcia Balzer (if a particular coin is eluding you, search for it here to figure out which of the lures will help you the most), my Meisterliche Angelrute der Kalu'ak, Wettergegerbter Angelhut with buff applied every 10 minutes, and a Angelstuhl for my poor, aching, Draenei butt to get this achievement.

On the upside, I got Angler von Legion and I also managed to read the 2 new Warcraft novels while doing this. It's nice to do with the Dalaran music in the background.

Long story short, prepare to settle in for a long fishing spree.

Kommentar von purpleblob

I used a character that just picked up fishing and with the basic Fishing Pole (aka no fishing bonus) for this achieve and it took me roughtly 7 hours and 997 casts.

I did use the coin items at the end to get the last three coins, but frankly my sample size would be too small to be significant and rather anecdotal.

Three last coins that took me about 1h was:
Gul'dan's Coin
Kor'vas Bloodthorn's Coin
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin

With Alchemical Bonding Agent, I got the Boomboom coin on first cast, but seems more like luck more than anything.

Couldn't get text copy to work for Fishing Buddy, but here's a screenshot for anyone interested in the catch rate stats.
(Yes, 12 failed casts because eating :( )

Kommentar von Tangolino

Any info on the bait needed to get Kur'Talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin? I've been on it for the last two days without any luck. I know RNG is RNG, but maybe the lures pointed on it's page (hypermagnetic and vortex) aren't the ones needed for it.

Does anyone with it remember what lure used when it was fished?

Thanks

Kommentar von Zeldeza

Boy, It was a mistake starting this at 3:30am - what went from fishing up a few coins turned into a three and a half hour fishing grind to collect them all. My last coin took me around 40 minutes to finally fish up.

At the three hour mark, I went from 700 to 800 fishing.

Kommentar von Spoonzilla

Working on data to see if there's any correlation between lures used and coins caught. I'll updated as I get more data. For now, I'm doing one lure at a time for a total of 50 casts. Here is my data so far:

Lure:
Alchemistisches Haftmittel x50 casts
Coins Caught:
Elothirs goldenes Blatt x3
Vydhars Holzgroschen x2
Blingtrons Botmünze x1
Addie Zischmoors Münze x1
Remulos' Siegel x1
Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen x1
Stellagosas Silbermünze x1
König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze x1
Jaulons Mal x1
Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen x1
Havis Münze x1
Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze x1
Oculeths Verschwindemünze x1
Torok Bluttotems Münze x1
Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra x1
Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze x1
Murkys Münze x1
Tyrandes Münze x1

Lure:
Hypermagnetischer Köder x50 casts
Coins Caught:
Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze x3
Oculeths Verschwindemünze x2
Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie x2
Blingtrons Botmünze x1
Nathanos Pestrufers Münze x1
Jaulons Mal x1
Malfurions Münze x1
Murkys Münze x1
Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur x1
Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen x1
Addie Zischmoors Münze x1
Kodas Siegel x1
Izal Weißmonds Münze x1
Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres x1
Okuna Langhauers Dublone x1
Runas' letzte Kupfermünze x1
Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel x1
Illidans Münze x1

Lure:
Auriphage Sardine x50 casts
Coins Caught:
Vydhars Holzgroschen x2
Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres x2
Die Münze x2
Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze x1
Elothirs goldenes Blatt x1
Oculeths Verschwindemünze x1
Kodas Siegel x1
Nathanos Pestrufers Münze x1
Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen x1
Remulos' Siegel x1
Runas' letzte Kupfermünze x1
Okuna Langhauers Dublone x1
Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze x1
Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden x1
Gul'dans Münze x1
Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld x1
Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig x1
Genn Graumähnes Münze x1

Kommentar von Jackalo

I just wanted to note that you can receive these coins in the mail and have it count towards the achievement. Got the achievement on my level one auction mule.

Kommentar von Rasmussen82

After 1251 catches and 254 coins, I finally got the coin I was after. You guessed it, the coin that pops the achievement spam, telling your guild mates, that you are a sad and lonely existence with nothing better to do, but to stare at a fishing bobber in a fountain.

In any case, I did this without using any lures or pole attachments and judging on the amount of duplicates I got, it doesn't seem like there is any coins more rare than others, they are purely based on RNG. I base this on the fact that my last coin was a 1 cobber vendor value and the coins I caught the most was evenly a 1 cobber and a 1 gold coin. That and the fact that the rest of my coins were somewhat evenly distributed in the numbers of duplicates I received, strongly suggest that the coins are RNG.

To diminish bad RNG I would advise to use the appropriate lures as soon as you caught somewhere between 1/2 to 2/3 of the required coins, as at that point you will start to catch a lot of duplicates.

Spoonzilla made a nice list over what lure goes for what coins. You can find it here

Kommentar von sanafey

Using Hypermagnetischer Köder only (and sometimes without the lure because the buff fell off) :

7x First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin
6x Torok Bloodtotem's Coin
5x Yowlon's Mark
4x Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin
4x God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
4x Allari the Souleater's Coin
4x Koda's Sigil
4x Guldan's Coin
3x Remulos' Sigil
3x Jarod Shadowsong's Coin
3x Illidan's Coin
3x Altruis the Sufferer's Coin
3x Kor'vas Bloodthorn
3x Boomboom Rullingsworth's Coin
3x Li Li's Coin
2x Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet
2x Cyana NightGlaive's Coin
2x Havi's Coin
2x Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin
2x Helya's Coin
2x Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin
2x Stellagosa's Silver Coin
2x Prince Farondis' Royal Seal
2x Okuna's Longtusk's Doubloon
2x Runas' Last Copper
1x Malfurion's Coin
1x Tyrande's
1x Daglop's Infernal
1x Coin of Golk the Rumble
1x Penelope's Heathrow's Allowance
1x Ly'eth Lunastre's Family Crest
1x The Coin
1x Lady Liadrin's Coin
1x Lunara's Coin
1x Izal Whitemoon's Coin
1x Elothir's Leaf
1x Kayne's Sunfury's Coin
Missing:
Senegos' Ancient Coin
Ooker's Dookat
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Murky's Coin
Addie Fizzlybog's Coin
The Candleking's Candelcoin
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Advisor Vandros' Coin
Jace Darkweaver's Coin
Blingtron's Botcoin
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String

I'll update with my catches
I caught a few where I am not sure if I used Hypermagnetic lure, so I didn't add those to the list..

Kommentar von hallayoyo

1749 casts, and i missed one coin for like 900 casts, a serious pain. I experienced a guy starting to fish when i missed the last coin. When he got it, his buddy had come aswell, and wouldnt you know he also got THE WHOLE achievment before me. I started to really think it was bugged for me, since ive gotten 3 of every coin except the missing one and Ladyy Liadrin's Coin.

Keep fishing!

Kommentar von Aletheua

For those who simply don't want to fish these up, for future reference, you CAN BUY AND SELL THEM ON THE AUCTION HOUSE.
If people would sell them, that is! I fished mine up, but I know if I had known I might have skipped a few.
Happy fishing!

Kommentar von DrunkenHyena

You can run this to find out how many coins you still need:
/run local c = 0; for i=0, GetAchievementNumCriteria(10722) do if(select(3,GetAchievementCriteriaInfo(10722,i)) == false) then c=c+1; end;end; print(c);

Kommentar von Xickez

Tip: Do this in a group, preferably friends/guildy's so you can see which coins fished up by who, to make it even easyer make a seperate "Chat' with just Loot shown in it so it wont get spammed by trade chat. (also to avoid &*!@heads that wanna make gold of your hands)

You CAN trade the coins but wil NOT recieve credit uppon trading them,however you WIL get credit for them if you MAIL it to yourself/others. (Hence me saying do this with Guildy's due to instand mail)

Tested and done this myself works as of 11-09-2016 wil mostlikely be hotfixed asap.

PS: Dont think many ppl know this yet since there are non on AH and most ppl probably have a Auto sell crap items so get instandly sold uppon talking to a vendor.

Your Welcome.

Kommentar von DeathMaster

In case you're wondering - yes, you can catch the same coin more than one.
Hell, you can catch the same coin three times in a row.

Kommentar von zeromic

The lure duration increase from the Tiefenlichtangler works on the coin lures.

Kommentar von Esinar

Just got this achievement after around 2 hours 40 minutes of fishing.

I decided to buy each of the 8 Lures from Marcia Chase, use them all one after another, then repeat this three more times (meaning I used a total of four of each Lure)

After using up the forth set of Lures, I found I was only missing one coin - Tyrande's Coin. People claimed it dropped when using the Hypermagnetic Lure so I then solely just used that and found my last coin after about 20 more minutes.

I recorded each of the coins I found during my hunt and have listed them below. If you Ctrl-F you can search for a coin that you're missing from my list and the associated Lure that will guarantee you find it eventually.

Hypermagnetic Lure:
Murky's Coin (x2)
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin (x3)
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin (x4)
Nathanos Brightcaller's Coin (x2)
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin (x3)
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest (x2)
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String (x3)
Runas' Last Copper (x2)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin (x2)
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin
Advisor Vandro's Coin (x2)
Stellagosa's Silver Coin (x3)
Kor'vas Bloodthorn's Coin (x3)
Remulo's Sigil (x2)
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin (x4)
Havi's Coin (x3)
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin (x2)
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
Li Li's Coin (x3)
Genn Greymane's Coin
Koda's Sigil (x2)
Malfurion's Coin
Coin of Golk the Rumble
Blingtron Botcoin (x2)
Elothir's Golden Leaf (2)
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin (x2)
Ooker's Dookat
Tyrande's Coin

Auriphagic Sardine:
Senegos' Ancient Coin
Murky's Coin (x2)
Izal Whitemoon's Coin
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Illidan's Coin (x3)
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest
The Candleking's Candlecoin (x3)
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin (x2)
Ooker's Dookat (x3)
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance (x3)
Li Li's Coin
Helya's Coin (x2)
Elothir's Golden Leaf (x2)
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin (x2)

Glob of Really Sticky Glue:
Remulo's Sigil
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin
The Coin (x2)
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin (x2)
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel (x3)
Gul'dan's Coin (x3)
Yowlon's Mark
Ooker's Dookat
Senegos' Ancient Coin
Prince Farondis's Royal Seal (x2)
Havi's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin
The Candleking's Candlecoin
Li Li's Coin (x2)
Kor'vas Bloosthorn's Coin
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin
Kayn Sunfury's Coin

Micro-Vortex Generator:
Kor'vas Bloosthorn's Coin (x2)
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin (x2)
Jace Darkweaver's Coin (x2)
Remulo's Sigil
Illidan's Coin (x3)
Havi's Coin (x2)
Runas' Last Copper (x2)
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Lady Liadrin's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest
Falara Nightsong's Coin (x6)
Allari the Souleater's Coin
Nathanos Brightcaller's Coin
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin (x3)
Gul'dan's Coin (x2)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Yowlon's Mark
Kayn Sunfury's Coin
The Coin

Wish Crystal:
Izal Whitemoon's Coin
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Yowlon's Mark (x3)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin (x2)
The Candleking's Candlecoin (x3)
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin (x5)
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String
Coin of Golk the Rumble (x3)
Falara Nightsong's Coin
Havi's Coin
Elothir's Golden Leaf
Li Li's Coin
Koda's Sigil (x2)
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin (x2)
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel

Alchemical Bonding Agent:
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin (x2)
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Illidan's Coin
Allari the Souleater's Coin
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin (x3)
Gul'dan's Coin (x4)
Elothir's Golden Leaf
Stellagosa's Silver Coin
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet
Torok's Bloodtotem's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest (x3)
Li Li's Coin (x2)
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin (x2)
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin
Blingtron's Botcoin
Helya's Coin
The Coin
Runas' Last Copper (x2)

Starfish on a String:
Havi's Coin
Coin of Golk the Rumble (x3)
Yowlon's Mark (x4)
Nathanos Brightcaller's Coin
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance (x3)
Koda's Sigil (x2)
Allari the Souleater's Coin
Queen Azshara's Royal Coin
Li Li's Coin
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel (x2)
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin (x2)
Senegos' Ancient Coin (x2)
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Runas' Last Copper (x3)
Ooker's Dookat
Advisor Vandros' Coin
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon
Jace Darkweaver's Coin
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Lunara's coin

Tiny Little Grabbing Apparatus:
Torok's Bloodtotem's Coin
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin (x4)
Elothir's Golden Leaf
Li Li's Coin (x2)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Yowlon's Mark (x3)
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin (x2)
Ooker's Dookat
Prince Farondis's Royal Seal
The Coin (x2)
Genn Greymane's Coin
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin (x2)
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel (x2)
Lady Liadrin's Coin
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
The Candleking's Candlecoin (x2)
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest

Other things to note:
- I have the fishing Artifact so my Lures last 4 minutes instead of 2
- As you can see many coins cross over and can be caught with different Lures
- Chance of fishing up a coin per cast seems to be around 50%.

Hope this helps.

Kommentar von 1242287

I decided to sit down and knock this out right away after getting legion fishing. Here are my results so that you can see about how long it is going to take you to complete this achievement.

It took a total of 1401 casts over a 4 hour 53 minute time span. The first hour I was getting the coins to drop rapidly. By the end of hour 3 I had all but 6 coins. By hour 4 I had only 2 coins remaining. The last 2 coins dropped within 5 minutes of each other at the very end. I reached 800 fishing skill before hour 2.

I used a Savage Fishing Pole with +4 fishing string, Nat's Drinking Hat, Nat Pagle's Extreme Anglin' Boots, and Worm Supreme as the lures.

My results are as follows:
Big Fountain Goldfish (1176 : 83.9%)
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal (8 : 0.6%)
The Candleking's Candlecoin (8 : 0.6%)
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin (7 : 0.5%)
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin (7 : 0.5%)
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin (6 : 0.4%)
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin (6 : 0.4%)
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin (6 : 0.4%)
Rax Sixtrigtger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin (6 : 0.4%)
Elothir's Golden Leaf (6 : 0.4%)
Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin (5 : 0.4%)
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance (5 : 0.4%)
Remulos' Sigil (5 : 0.4%)
Falara Nightsong's Coin (5 : 0.4%)
Tyrande's Coin (5 : 0.4%)
Kor'vas Bloodthorn's Coin (5 : 0.4%)
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin (5 : 0.4%)
Prince Farondis's Royal Seal (5 : 0.4%)
Helya's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Koda's Sigil (4 : 0.3%)
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Kayn Sunfury's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Lunara's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Vydhar's Wooden Nickle (4 : 0.3%)
Izal Whitemoon's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Gul'dan's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Allari the Souleater's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Genn Greymane's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Malfurion's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Murky's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Li Li's Coin (4 : 0.3%)
Blingtron's Botcoin (4 : 0.3%)
Runas' Last Copper (4 : 0.3%)
Advisor Vandros' Coin (3 : 0.2%)
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin (3 : 0.2%)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Havi's Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Senegos' Ancient Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Lady Liadrin's Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest (3 : 0.2%)
The Coin (3 : 0.2%)
Ooker's Dookat (3 : 0.2%)
Yowlon's Mark (2 : 0.1%)
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon (2 : 0.1%)
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String (2 : 0.1%)
Stellagosa's Silver Coin (2 : 0.1%)
Illidan's Coin (2 : 0.1%)
Coin of Golk the Rumble (2 : 0.1%)
Jace Darkweaver's Coin (2 : 0.1%)
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet (1 : 0.1%)
Magistrix Elisande's Coin (1 : 0.1%)

Forgive me for any typing errors as I had to type all this out by hand. If anybody knows how to copy results from Fishing Buddy, please let me know.

Kommentar von Marigan

Here's a link showing what I've recorded as the chance to acquire the above listed items to get the achievement.

http://imgur.com/a/sR1hO

I started out at level 700 without fishing anywhere else in Legion. I ended at 778 in under 4 hours.

Used the following items as added buffs (this is why I was +259 in skill):

Sharpened Tuskarr Spear +15
Worm Supreme +200
Weather-Beaten Fishing Hat +5 (kept forgetting the additional +10)
Nat Pagle's Extreme Anglin' Boots +5
Mastercraft Kalu'ak Fishing Pole +30 and +4
And then whatever 2 minute item buffs Marcia Chase offered in order to get the specific coin

Kommentar von Buffbringer

Well, by reading the comments here, i can tell i was very lucky. I decided to get this achievement this afternoon, so i made one session of fishing by the fountain. What i did was talk to Marcia Chase and buy the 8 special lures, and consumed all of them one after the other. Then i would buy them all again, and so on.
After 2:30 hours and 437 casts, i got my last coin. For the last 3 coins, i tried to narrow down to a common lure for them, and got to Hypermagnetic Lure. The coins were: Stellagosa's Silver Coin, Advisor Vandros' Coin and First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin.
I don't know if this was the best method, but it consumed little time.

Kommentar von 1246921

Time Spent: 6 hours
Casts Made: 1319
Gold Fish Caught: 891
Having 3 sets of coins before fishing up Liadrin's: priceless

Kommentar von Matyivagyok

My personal datas from Fishing Buddy, used all kind of special baits.
http://i.imgur.com/omgImJ7.jpg

Kommentar von 826041

So my experience so far.

Used each lure 2x a piece and got all but 6 coins. I scoured the data here to piece together which lures to use to get my missing coins.

Esinar's data is the most accurate by far.

Some things I've noticed. The high count coins (meaning everyone who responded who got 3+ coins with varying lures) are generic. You don't need a lure for those coins, you'd fish them up anyway.

I've used the starfish on a string 3 times and it's the only one to consistently give me 2 coins every 3rd or 4th cast (sometimes twice in a row.)

As of this posting... I'm missing only 4 coins. Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet, Jace Darkweaver's Coin, Lady Liadrin's Coin, and Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String.

My advice to newcomers... use each lure at least twice, (3 times is preference), and make your way down the list. Should be 2 hours tops to get most of it done. Despite it being a long list, this one is WAY easier than the original dalaran fountain achievement.

Kommentar von Isabliss

Finally got it - took 1074 casts - 345 to get the last coin.
Last coin I had to get was Ker'Talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin. I had on the Glob of Really Sticky Glue lure. I tried it with the Hypermagnetic and the Micro Vortex A LOT - and it never showed up.

Others in the rare to catch list for me were
1 Murky's Coin
1 Senegos' Ancient Coin
2 Jarod Shadowsong's Coin
2 Gul'dan Coin
2 Izal Whitmoon Coin
2 Lunara's Coin
2 Addie Fizzlebog's Coin
2 Blingtron's Botcoin

I mostly just kept rotating the lure use - I used the Starfish a lot as it gave 2 coins many many times! Had 914 Skill.

Kommentar von Lomack

Fishing with 960 skill: Underlight Angler (enchanted +5), Fishing Hat, Boots, Lure from the Hat
The special lures were lasting 4min 15sec for me with my artifact pole.

When through each special lure in turn.
After round 1 (~40 min): Missing 15 coins
After round 2 (~40 min): Missing 7 coins
After round 3 (~40 min): Missing 3 coins

At this point I started using select lures that others had reported catching those last 3 missing coins with.

It took me another 40+ lures to get the last 3...

Falara Nightsong's Coin - caught using Gob of Really Sticky Glue, after about 4 lures
Malfurion's Coin - caught using Hypermagnetic Lure, after about 22 lures
Advisor Vandros' Coin - caught using Starfish on a String, I stopped counting lures after about 40 total. But, I did use about 15 of this particular lure before the coin came up.

Total time spent: ~ 7+hrs.... Persistence > Luck

Kommentar von Raa007

~~Has something changed? I was fishing these up fairly regularly without any lures last week, now I'm hardly catching any coins without a lure...~~
Nevermind, it's just really bad RNG. :)

Kommentar von kirasumi

I found a higher fish rate on the coins while using the Enlarged Fishing Bobber :)

Kommentar von Eluna

A little over 4 hours and 1289 throws later. I have no clue what caught what of the lures, but you can look at other comments for that. The worst was Prince Farondis's Royal Seal, which took almost two hours to get.. Bad luck I guess.

Item - Throws (Percentage of things caught)
Big Fountain Goldfish - 925 (71.8%)
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin - 17 (1.3%)
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin - 12 (0.9%)
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin - 12 (0.9%)
King-Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin - 11 (0.9%)
The Coin - 11 (0.9%)
Yowlon's Mark - 11 (0.9%)
Runas' Last Copper - 11 (0.9%)
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet - 10 (0.8%)
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin - 10 (0.8%)
Allari the Souleater's Coin - 10 (0.8%)
Gul'dan's Coin - 10 (0.8%)
Remulos' Sigil - 10 (0.8%)
Li Li's Coin - 10 (0.8%)
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin - 9 (0.7%)
Ooker's Dookat - 9 (0.7%)
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin - 9 (0.7%)
Coin of Golk the Rumble - 8 (0.6%)
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel - 8 (0.6%)
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin - 8 (0.6%)
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest - 7 (0.5%)
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin - 7 (0.5%)
Havi's Coin - 7 (0.5%)
Murkey's Coin - 7 (0.5%)
Illidan's Coin - 7 (0.5%)
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin - 6 (0.5%)
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin - 6 (0.5%)
Lunara's Coin - 6 (0.5%)
Senegos Ancient Coin - 6 (0.5%)
Jace Darkweaver's Coin - 5 (0.4%)
Izal Whitemoon's Coin - 5 (0.4%)
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal - 5 (0.4%)
Falara Nightsong's Coin - 5 (0.4%)
The Candleking's Candlecoin - 5 (0.4%)
Kor'vas Bloodthorn's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Tyrande's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Advisor Vandros' Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Elothir's Golden Leaf - 4 (0.3%)
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String - 4 (0.3%)
Penelop Heathrow's Allowance - 4 (0.3%)
Malfurion's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Helya's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin - 4 (0.3%)
Koda's Sigil - 3 (0.2%)
Genn Greymane's Coin - 3 (0.2%)
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin - 3 (0.2%)
Kayn Sunfury's Coin - 3 (0.2%)
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin - 2 (0.2%)
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon - 2 (0.2%)
Blingtron's Botcoin - 2 (0.2%)
Lady Liadrin's Coin - 2 (0.2%)
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin - 2 (0.2%)
Partially Eaten Fish - 2 (0.2%)
Magistrix Elisande's Coin - 2 (0.2%)
Drowned Rat - 2 (0.2%)
Sewer Carp - 1 (0.1%)
Prince Farondis's Royal Seal - 1 (0.1%)
Magic Eater - 1 (0.1%)

Kommentar von Ylts

To buy all of the lures from the vendor, use this macro:
/run BuyMerchantItem(3,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(4,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(5,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(6,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(7,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(8,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(9,1)
/run BuyMerchantItem(10,1)

They don't stack so you can only have one of each

Use only once after 2-5 minutes, depends on your artifact fishing pole
#showtooltip
/use Hypermagnetic Lure
/use Auriphagic Sardine
/use Glob of Really Sticky Glue
/use Micro-Vortex Generator
/use Wish Crystal
/use Alchemical Bonding Agent
/use Starfish on a String
/use Tiny Little Grabbing Apparatus

Edit: Fixed the buy macro, looks like i posted earlier version of it

Kommentar von Gracin

Went through one round of lures, 860 fishing skill and the artifact at level 15, so I'm getting 5min lures. Wish I would have thought to keep a record of why coins were pulled in with what lure, I'll try and do that on my next pass. Overall I'd say it went about on par with other people's results. I finished my last lure and have 17 coins remaining.

Kommentar von Chidsuey

I may start my own data sheet for this, but I wanted people to note this if they start making their own.

When you record your data, you need to do it by bait session, and not altogether for one bait. What I mean is, if you use Wish Crystal 8 times, you need 8 sets of data, not one large one for Wish Crystal. The reason for this is that the bait is a seperate roll. I got two coins at one time with a bait active. That means if you're homogenizing all the data, you maybe including coins you were just lucky to get regardless of the bait. By separating them, and with enough data, we should be able to weed out the non-bait coins we find.

Kommentar von GalleVaming

Took me like... 6 Hours of fishing. Got several things 25 times.. and the last 5 and especially the last one took very long.. it's just random. The lures aren't different... it's just luck. I hope there is no new fountain any time soon.

Kommentar von Volleynova

Got it done in one sitting, took about 3.5 hours. Always kept the extra lures up. So many duplicate coins from Queen Azshara, but only after the 2nd hour, it wasn't even funny.

My last three coins were:

Prince Farondris' Royal Seal (1)
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet (1)
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal (7)

Kommentar von lalkzo

2 coins at the same time can be caught which happens quite frequently. (7.0.1)

Kommentar von Thannya

Finally I have completed this achievement. As many people stated before me, it is completely random, lures have nothing to do with the coin you are still missing.
You know the feeling when you look at the list of coins and somehow you know which one will give you pain :)? First day, I caught most of those, I was missing eight coins. Second day, I fished up the remaining seven, and took me another few hours on the third day for the last one - Tyrande's coin.
Anyway, it is done, only I wish we could get some reward, like the last time.

And, yes, it took me 1072 casts in total. I really didn't keep track of how many for each coin.

Kommentar von Ladronia

Having just completed this achievement in one sitting, I thought I should share my information to help out others on their fishing adventure. Unfortunately, I did not keep track of what I caught with each specific lure but I can say that I had 1000+ fishing skill using Tiefenlichtangler and Nats Hut and always fished with the lures sold by the nearby vendor. While I don't believe that your overall fishing skill will matter, having the artifact pole does increase your lure timer from two minutes to four.

As for those lures, I started out using one of each of the eight different types and ended up buying a three full sets. After going through those 24 lures, I was missing only Tyrandes Münze and after checking out some of the other posts here it seemed that either Hypermagnetischer Köder or Seestern mit Faden would give me the best chance to fish up that specific coin. The first lure did not work, but the starfish yielded the coin I was looking for within the first three casts.

All in told, it took a total of 388 casts and somewhere just south of two hours to gather all of the coins.

Some random information from my session:

Total coins caught: 212 (54.6% attach rate)
Junk fish caught: 387 Großer Brunnengoldfisch, 1 Kanalisationskarpfen
First coin caught: Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld
Last coin caught: Tyrandes Münze
Coins caught the most: Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra and Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze (10 times each)
Coins caught only once: Jarod Schattensangs Münze, Izal Weißmonds Münze, Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze, Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis, Lady Liadrins Münze, Genn Graumähnes Münze, Tyrandes Münze

And I don't know if it means anything, but I caught Malfurions Münze alongside Tyrandes Münze in my final cast.

Kommentar von Manniala

Remember, it states "Better chance" so even with a lure that won't give a better chance for xxxxx, you can still get that coin.

So by taking let's say Auriphage Sardine and lets say it will give you a better chance for 5 of the coins, you can still get any of the other coins while having that lure, just the 5 coins will have a higher chance of dropping.

So when people states i got the xxxxx while i had xxxxx lure, it doesn't really mean that, that specific lure really helped getting that coin.
Need a lot of more fishing and posting, what lure was used, and after a lot of data posted, you can start to get a better understanding which one really helped and which was just a random chance.

Kommentar von Marhault

I was able to fish out every coin except Tyrandes Münze without any bait. I bought two Hypermagnetischer Köder from Marcia Balzer and it dropped on the second cast of the second lure to finish the achievement.

Kommentar von pat33

My last coin was a blingtron's botcoin, got a little mad and tried this combo : Starfish on a String + Arcane Lure

Got my coin with 2 cast :) Maybe it was luck ... I'll never know

Kommentar von Djuntas

Another achievement that was easy. Legion unlike previous expansion has made these on paper hard once, rather doable. 3 hours it took me, maybe less, but I think I wasted like 30 mins using bad lure at the end on last coin.

Kommentar von Alvtron

Here is my experience while getting this achievement.

Date/patch: 18th of January 2017, patch 7.1.5

Equipment:

Total fishing skill: 1004

Time: 2 hours and 40 minutes (14:00-16:40/2:00PM-4:40PM)

I purchased all 8 baits from Marcia Balzer and used them along with my special lure from Nats Hut, Angelhutköder.

Remaining coins after +1 hour (15:00/3:00PM):

Remaining coins after +30 minutes (15:30/3:30PM):

Here I started to buy specific bait for these two based on other peoples data. I used Auriphage Sardine
and Hypermagnetischer Köder.

Remaining coins after +30 minutes (16:00/4:00PM):

Magistrix Elisandes Münze

Here I used Auriphage Sardine, Hypermagnetischer Köder, Alchemistisches Haftmittel and Wunschkristall.

I managed to get Magistrix Elisandes Münze after 40 minutes with Hypermagnetischer Köder.

Additional catch: In addition to the coins, I fished up 4x Kanalisationskarpfen, 3x Magiesauger and 1x Ertrunkene Ratte.

Kommentar von Araselo

This achievement does not grant a hidden artifact appearance (even with a maxed out Underlight Angler). :C

Kommentar von wolf1438

Just a little observations of mine. I did this achievment on lvl 6 with skill 48 in fishing. Because of that lvl i could not use special lure. It took me about 5 hours to fish up all coins and i get 678 fishing skill. I noticed the drop rate of all coins are somehow balanced. I didn't get more than 7 coins of same type. So if you just start new character and want to lvl up fishing skill with some achievment benefit, this is good way how to do it.

Kommentar von anic8038

You do NOT need the lures to complete this achievement. It took me about 1000 casts and no lures. Save your gold!

Kommentar von Luphian

After 1594 catches and about 5 hours, I finally managed to pull off this achievement.

Equipment:
Wettergegerbter Angelhut
Juwelenbesetzte Angelrute

Fishing Skill:
Started at 750-ish, and ended with 800 fairly quickly.

I started out by systematically buying each of the 8 lures:
Hypermagnetischer Köder
Auriphage Sardine
Klecks echt klebrigen Leims
Mikrovortexgenerator
Wunschkristall
Alchemistisches Haftmittel
Seestern mit Faden
Winzig kleines Greifgerät

I then used them one by one, attaching them, as the previous one ran out, while using Extraordinärer Wurm as bait on top of the lure, together with Übergroßer Schwimmer, just to make it easier for myself.
After this procedure, I ended up only missing four of the coins after an hour/hour and a half, and these were:

Tyrandes Münze
Malfurions Münze
Genn Graumähnes Münze
Lady Liadrins Münze

I eventually obtained Lady Liadrins Münze and Genn Graumähnes Münze, and was left with the two others, and looked up the achievement to find help, where it said to use the Hypermagnetischer Köder on the most comments and suggestions to get the remaining two coins.

I continued the fishing, but stopped using the Extraordinärer Wurm as I didn't seem to see any specific difference in what I caught.
Eventually, after 100-200 more catches, I obtained Malfurions Münze, and only Tyrandes Münze remained.

As mentioned, I read to use the Hypermagnetischer Köder, but after using it for more than 400 tries, I went specifically to the page for Tyrandes Münze to look for more answers and help.
In there, people were saying that Seestern mit Faden was the proper choice, and I then began using that.

I used that for the remainder of the time, and after using it 10-15 times, I managed to get last coin, Tyrandes Münze.

From what it seems, I turned out to be one of the unluckier people trying for the achievement, as everyone else seemed to have gotten it within 2-4 hours.

Here are my stats from Fishing Buddy:

COIN - AMOUNT CAUGHT: % TO CATCH

Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen - 23: 1.4%
Havis Münze - 20: 1.4%
Bummbumm von Brullows Münze - 19: 1.2%
Kodas Siegel - 18: 1.1%
Oculeths Verschwindemünze - 18: 1.1%
Runas' letzte Kupfermünze - 17: 1.1%
Gul'dans Münze - 16: 1%
Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze - 16: 1%
Elothirs goldenes Blatt - 16: 1%
Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze - 15: 0.9%
Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra - 15: 0.9%
Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze - 15: 0.9%
Jaulons Mal - 15: 0.9%
Die Münze - 15: 0.9%
Torok Bluttotems Münze - 14: 0.9%
Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden - 14: 0.9%
Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie - 11: 0.7%
Cyana Nachtgleves Münze - 11: 0.7%
Izal Weißmonds Münze - 11: 0.7%
Murkys Münze - 10: 0.6%
Vydhars Holzgroschen - 10: 0.6%
Jace Düsterwebers Münze - 10: 0.6%
Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin - 10: 0.6%
Berater Vandros' Münze - 9: 0.6%
Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze - 9: 0.6%
Blingtrons Botmünze - 9: 0.6%
Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze - 9: 0.6%
Remulos' Siegel - 9: 0.6%
Addie Zischmoors Münze - 8: 0.5%
Stellagosas Silbermünze - 8: 0.5%
Illidans Münze - 8: 0.5%
Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig - 7: 0.4%
Li Lis Münze - 7: 0.4%
Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze - 7: 0.4%
Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres - 7: 0.4%
Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara - 7: 0.4%
Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur - 7: 0.4%
Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld - 7: 0.4%
Falara Nachtweises Münze - 6: 0.4%
Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze - 6: 0.4%
Jarod Schattensangs Münze - 6: 0.4%
Nathanos Pestrufers Münze - 6: 0.4%
Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen - 6: 0.4%
Helyas Münze - 6: 0.4%
Magistrix Elisandes Münze - 5: 0.3%
Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel - 5: 0.3%
Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze - 5: 0.3%
Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis - 5: 0.3%
Okuna Langhauers Dublone - 4: 0.3%
König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze - 4: 0.3%
Lunaras Münze - 4: 0.3%
Senegos' uralte Münze - 3: 0.2%
Malfurions Münze - 3: 0.2%
Lady Liadrins Münze - 2: 0.1%
Genn Graumähnes Münze - 2: 0.1%
Tyrandes Münze - 1: 0.1%

I hope these numbers can be of use to someone!

Good luck on the coin/achievement hunt!

Kommentar von fendred

My experience with this achievement (at 1015 fishing skill);

- The lures don't affect which coins you fish up (I tried targeting certain coins with the lures recommended in other comments, fished up mostly coins matched to different lures, finally fished up target coins with a different lure or no lure at all)

-The lures DO increase your chance to fish up any coin (with no lure I would regularly get 6 consecutive casts with no coin and rarely get consecutive casts with coin, with a lure I'd often get consecutive coins and rarely long consecutive casts without)

-It is possible to fish up multiple coins in one cast (only happened to me once, two copper coins, Starfish on a String lure)

-About 600 casts to finish the achievement, about 100 of which were on the final coin (Queen Azshara's Royal Seal, using Starfish but tried Glue and Micro Vortex a number of times first)

Kommentar von Angerona

with Wish Crystal lure:
Havi's Coin 3X
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin
Blingtron's Botcoin 2X
Kayn Sunfury's Coin
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin
Remulos' Sigil
Izal Whitemoon's Coin
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin
Gul'dan's Coin
Lunara's Coin
Coin of Golk the Rumble 2X
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance
Tyrande's Coin 2X
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Runas' Last Copper
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String
The Candleking's Candelcoin
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin 2X

with Glob of Really Sticky Glue lure:
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet 2X
Kor'vas Bloosthorn's Coin
Izal Whitemoon's Coin
The Coin
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin 2X
Prince Farondis' Royal Seal 2X
Stellagosa's Silver Coin
Coin of Golk the Rumble 2X
The Candleking's Candelcoin 2X
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Allari the Souleater's Coin 2X
Ooker's Dookat
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin 2X
Kayn Sunfury's Coin
Yowlon's Mark
Remulos' Sigil
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest

Kommentar von Deien

I posted this on Blingtron's Botcoin page but thought it might help someone here as well.

My last coin to get was Blingtron's.
There seemed to be a number of successful pins on the map for this coin under 52.8 65.4 so I put a way point at that location and stood as close to on top of it as I could. I then fished starting left toward Marcia Chase, then through the middle and finally to the right toward Hannis Shoalwalker. I actually fished up Blingtron's coin right next to the edge of the pool there on the right.

Some notes:
At the time I caught Blingtron's coin I was not using any extra bait from Marcia or any other source; just my level 800 fishing and the 40 bonus from my pole and hat.
I caught the most coins facing toward the left. That is where I caught Allari the Souleater's Coin leaving me only needing Blingtron's..
I actually caught one coin in the planter behind Marcia and over to the right I caught Malfurion's Coin in the pile of debris against the wall of the Glorious Goods shop, so if your cast does not land in the pool, if you can trace your line to your bobber and find it with your mouse then go ahead and let it hook something!
Most everyone tells me it makes no difference, but I was wearing Talisman of True Treasure Tracking at the time, and throughout working on this achievement. It only took a day out of my weekend to get all the rest of the coins and then part of this evening to get the last 2 coins.

Good luck to all.

Kommentar von AlexL1118

As some people have mentioned, you can get two coins from one cast, but in my case such luck happened only when I used lure "Starfish on a String" (rarely of course).

Kommentar von stilettosoldier

JUST FINISHED IT.

Thanks to the other posters here for the tips on lures to use... in the end, I just did them all random and got the final coin I needed -- Lady Liadrin's Coin. Not that it matters but I used my Mastercraft Kalu'ak Fishing Pole and my Weather-Beaten Fishing Hat just to make it feel official ;)

Here were my stats from fishing buddy:

1480 casts
978 Big Fountain Goldfish
26 Sewer Carp

A whole bunch of each of the coins except for Helya's Coin, Blingtron's Botcoin and Lady Liadrin's Coin. Only got one of each of those.

All in all, it was a grind for sure but well worth it just to have it completed.

Good luck and happy fishing all!

Kommentar von WebGremlin

As Drowned Mana cannot be fished at skill 1, I thought I'd combine leveling fishing with this achievement. I got it up to 504 before fishing the last coin I needed. Worth it :)

Kommentar von Ffion

1400 casts in total to get this achievement. I was down to Queen Azshara's Royal Seal with approx. 900 casts. Took another 500 to get one coin. Good luck out there.

Kommentar von Melandroso

Based on an analysis for the reported catches on this page, the page for each coin and the page for each bait, the below would appear to be a solid way to go about starting the farming for this achievement.

1. Use Hypermagnetischer Köder until you have caught Blingtrons Botmünze.

2. Then use Mikrovortexgenerator until you have caught Berater Vandros' Münze and Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur.

3. Then check the pages for the coins you are missing and select the most appropriate lure. Good choices are likely to be Alchemistisches Haftmittel and Seestern mit Faden.

4. As you catch more of the coins you have been missing, keep checking the pages for the specific coins you are missing for a good bait choice. If you can, pick a bait that can catch more than one of the coins you are missing.

Kommentar von Aratronus

So, I've been doing trying to do this achievement lately and if you're reading this, then like me you came here to get some stats on how rare these drops are. I can tell you that I have a significant sample size (over 6 hours in the past two days fishing in the Legion-Dalaran Fountain and over 700+ casts). My fishing skill started at somewhere around 75-100, and is now at 544, but somewhere around 400 I stopped getting a skill point for every cast and now it's every few casts). I kept every coin including it's duplicate in my bag to track.

Lady Liadrin's Coin is by far the rarest drop as it is the only coin I have yet to get. Given the amount of time it has taken, number of casts, varying and rotational use of all the lures, I can scarcely imagine that this coin (let alone the others) has the same drop rate as the rest. That, or I have had the worst luck. Here is a break down of my catches within those 6 hours, 700+ casts (sorted by most to least caught):

Koda's Sigil - 16
The Candleking's Candelcoin - 14
Yowlon's Mark - 14
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin - 13
Coin of Golk the Rumble - 12
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest - 12
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin - 11
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin - 11
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin - 10
Runas' Last Copper - 10
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin - 10
The Coin - 10
Elothir's Golden Leaf - 9
Li Li's Coin - 9
Murky's Coin - 9
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin - 9
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin - 8
Havi's Coin - 8
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin - 8
Prince Farondis' Royal Seal - 8
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal - 8
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel - 8
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin - 7
Blingtron's Botcoin - 7
Falara Nightsong's Coin - 7
Illidan's Coin - 7
Kayn Sunfury's Coin - 7
Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin - 7
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin - 6
Korvas Bloodthorn's Coin - 6
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin - 6
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin - 6
Remulos' Sigil - 6
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin - 6
Genn Greymane's Coin - 5
Gul'dan's Coin - 5
Izal Whitemoon's Coin - 5
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin - 5
Tyrande's Coin - 5
Helya's Coin - 4
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet - 4
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin - 4
Malfurion's Coin - 4
Ooker's Dookat - 4
Senegos' Ancient Coin - 4
Stellagosa's Silver Coin - 4
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin - 3
Advisor Vandros' Coin - 3
Jace Darkweaver's Coin - 3
Magistrix Elisande's Coin - 3
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance - 3
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String - 2
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon - 2
Allari the Souleater's Coin - 1
Lunara's Coin - 1
Lady Liadrin's Coin - 0

Sum: 379 coins (in case it helps anyone wanting to use this to calculate probabilities)

Note: I did not include percentages because there are too many variables to consider. For one, there are 56 coins, 700+ casts, and each with their own varying degree of probability. Throughout this, I used all available lures during varying times (sometimes no lure at all) and certain lures were used more than others. I did not, unfortunately, keep track of those numbers. Calculating probabilities based on these factors is probably best left to someone much better at it than I.

This is mainly to give you a general idea visually of which coins are the least likely to drop, but not at all the order you can expect to get them. Others may in fact get Lady Liadrin's coin and the other least likely ones fairly early on. If you are fortunate to get the 3 rarest early on, the rest should be fairly easy, but either way this achievement will take a long time to complete so be mindful of that if you choose to pursue it (whether it's just in your downtime between questing/raiding or you just want a lazy afternoon of music/tv and WoW fishing).

Good luck and happy fishing!

Kommentar von Zidane3838

Großer Brunnengoldfisch: 1110
Gul'dans Münze: 13
Jaulons Mal: 12
Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres: 11
Kodas Siegel: 10
Li Lis Münze: 10
Elothirs goldenes Blatt: 10
Vydhars Holzgroschen: 10
Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen: 9
Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze: 9
Lunaras Münze: 8
Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze: 8
Murkys Münze: 8
Die Münze: 8
Remulos' Siegel: 8
Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze: 8
Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze: 7
Runas' letzte Kupfermünze: 7
Tyrandes Münze: 7
Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden: 7
Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze: 7
Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig: 7
Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen: 6
Nathanos Pestrufers Münze: 6
Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra: 6
Helyas Münze: 6
Malfurions Münze: 6
Genn Graumähnes Münze: 6
Illidans Münze: 5
Havis Münze: 5
Falara Nachtweises Münze: 5
Bummbumm von Brullows Münze: 5
Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie: 5
Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel: 5
Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin: 5
Torok Bluttotems Münze: 5
Jace Düsterwebers Münze: 5
Senegos' uralte Münze: 5
Okuna Langhauers Dublone: 5
Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis: 4
Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze: 4
Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze: 4
Stellagosas Silbermünze: 4
Cyana Nachtgleves Münze: 4
Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze: 4
Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld: 4
Blingtrons Botmünze: 4
Magistrix Elisandes Münze: 4
Jarod Schattensangs Münze: 3
König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze: 3
Berater Vandros' Münze: 3
Izal Weißmonds Münze: 3
Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur: 2
Addie Zischmoors Münze: 2
Oculeths Verschwindemünze: 2
Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara: 1
Lady Liadrins Münze: 1 <- took me three hours alone

Total: 1441
Total time: 5hours 30minutes
For the last three hours I was using Auriphage Sardine rather sporadically in hopes of getting Lady Liadrin's coin faster... Not sure it helped me much.

Kommentar von Zenhunter

Last three for me were:

3. Genn Greymane's Coin
2. Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
1. Queen Azshara's Royal Seal

Took me less than 2 hours to get to the final three using every kind of lure, in order, over and over. I was at 1015 fishing (800+ 5/150 from Nat's Hat and +60 from Underlight Angler (which had 20 traits).

I kept using the Hypermagnetic Lure trying to get Ravencrest's Coin and got Genn instead, then I swapped to Glob of Sticky Glue, I got Kur'talos and Queen Azshara with the Glob within 10 casts. Overall it took me about 3 hours.

Kommentar von Salus

I got Lady Liadrin's Coin using the lure Auriphagic Sardine.

Kommentar von Currently

It took me just under three hours to complete this achievement. I used a variety of different baits listed in this thread. However, if you are starting out I would recommend using Seestern mit Faden as you can get two coins at once. I caught 529 Großer Brunnengoldfisch during this whole process, too.

Kommentar von Armak

It took me roughly 4.5 hours and 1192 casts at 860 fishing skill (800 + artifact pole). I fished 408 coins (36.1%). The last coin took 331 casts (Elisande's). After 220 casts I was already roughly at 42/56.
Except for the Seestern mit Faden, no lure brought a measurable difference. We'd possibly need tens (or hundreds) of thousands of catches to find out which coin they favor (if any). As often, the comment section here somewhat confuses. There is no logical connection between using a lure and catching an item after x casts with this lure, as we saw people reporting not using any lure at all, needing less casts than I did. At the beginning I was mislead by some of the comments. After realising that you don't gain much benefit from lures, I used the Starfish more often than others, because I liked getting two coins at once.

Statistics

Read: I had one coin (Oculeth's), which I fished 22 times.

22: 1 (Oculeth)
21: 1 (Rax)
20: 0
19: 0
18: 0
17: 0
16: 2
15: 2
14: 0
13: 4
12: 0
11: 4
10: 2
09: 0
08: 3
07: 4
06: 10
05: 6
04: 3
03: 7
02: 4
01: 3

Kommentar von baloonknot

got Korvas Bloodthorn's Coin with Auriphagic Sardine

Kommentar von Sluggzo

Did this tonight as part of my last-chance Legion cleanup. Took under three hours from start to finish (mercifully way faster than the old Wrath coin achieves).

The first hour, I used the Starfish lure exclusively, was consistently pulling 18-20+ coins every five minutes and quickly had 50 of the 57 coins fished up.

I tried each of the other lures and the drop rates were awful in comparison. Most produced ~8-10 coins for each lure; the sardine one gave a pitiful 4 coins, so I went back to the starfish for my last few.

Of my last four coins, two were Tyrande and Prince Farondis, which I've seen mentioned in these comments a few times. I fished up both with the starfish, in case anyone's wondering if it's possible. My last was Allari the Souleater, also fished up with the starfish lure.

Happy fishing!

Kommentar von Salokz

With the new profession system it took me a little bit less then 2 hours to complete the achievement. I started with Legion Fishing 1 and I used Knöcherne Angelrute and Wettergegerbter Angelhut. I needed around 490 casts to get all the coins.

Kommentar von Ximena

Speaking as someone whom if it weren't for bad luck I would have no luck at all, this achievement should be added as a Feat of Strength... FINALLY completed it today after fishing up the elusive Jarod Schattensangs Münze with a Mikrovortexgenerator.

Kommentar von Kraylo

Coins are listed in order of frequency. I didn't keep track of how many casts I made with each lure, but I tried switching them out pretty regularly. Also, Magistrix Elisandes Münze was the last one caught for the achieve.

Hypermagnetic Lure:

6 - Torok Bluttotems Münze
4 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
4 - Kodas Siegel
4 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
3 - Li Lis Münze
3 - Nathanos Pestrufers Münze
2 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
2 - Cyana Nachtgleves Münze
2 - Falara Nachtweises Münze
2 - Gul'dans Münze
2 - Havis Münze
2 - Jarod Schattensangs Münze
2 - Oculeths Verschwindemünze
2 - Runas' letzte Kupfermünze
1 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
1 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
1 - Illidans Münze
1 - Jace Düsterwebers Münze
1 - Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze
1 - König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze
1 - Malfurions Münze
1 - Okuna Langhauers Dublone
1 - Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld
1 - Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara
1 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
1 - Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze
1 - Stellagosas Silbermünze
1 - Die Münze
1 - Tyrandes Münze

Auriphagic Sardine

5 - Li Lis Münze
4 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
4 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
4 - Genn Graumähnes Münze
3 - Gul'dans Münze
3 - Havis Münze
3 - Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel
3 - Malfurions Münze
3 - Oculeths Verschwindemünze
3 - Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen
3 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
3 - Runas' letzte Kupfermünze
3 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze
2 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
2 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
2 - Falara Nachtweises Münze
2 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
2 - Murkys Münze
2 - Vydhars Holzgroschen
1 - Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin
1 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
1 - Cyana Nachtgleves Münze
1 - Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur
1 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
1 - Helyas Münze
1 - Jace Düsterwebers Münze
1 - Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze
1 - Lunaras Münze
1 - Nathanos Pestrufers Münze
1 - Remulos' Siegel
1 - Senegos' uralte Münze
1 - Die Münze

Glob of Really Sticky Glue

3 - Falara Nachtweises Münze
3 - Runas' letzte Kupfermünze
3 - Die Münze
2 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
2 - Gul'dans Münze
2 - Helyas Münze
2 - König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze
2 - Lunaras Münze
2 - Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara
2 - Remulos' Siegel
2 - Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze
2 - Jaulons Mal
1 - Berater Vandros' Münze
1 - Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin
1 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
1 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
1 - Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra
1 - Izal Weißmonds Münze
1 - Kodas Siegel
1 - Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze
1 - Li Lis Münze
1 - Malfurions Münze
1 - Nathanos Pestrufers Münze
1 - Okuna Langhauers Dublone
1 - Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig
1 - Senegos' uralte Münze
1 - Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze
1 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze
1 - Vydhars Holzgroschen

Micro-Vortex Generator

6 - Die Münze
4 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
3 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
3 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
3 - Havis Münze
2 - Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin
2 - Cyana Nachtgleves Münze
2 - Gul'dans Münze
2 - Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze
2 - Malfurions Münze
2 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
2 - Remulos' Siegel
2 - Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze
2 - Jaulons Mal
1 - Berater Vandros' Münze
1 - Blingtrons Botmünze
1 - Kodas Siegel
1 - Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze
1 - Li Lis Münze
1 - Oculeths Verschwindemünze
1 - Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze
1 - Tyrandes Münze

Wish Crystal

9 - Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra
5 - Murkys Münze
4 - Izal Weißmonds Münze
4 - Li Lis Münze
3 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
3 - Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel
3 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
3 - Jaulons Mal
2 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
2 - Havis Münze
2 - Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze
2 - Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig
2 - Senegos' uralte Münze
2 - Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze
1 - Addie Zischmoors Münze
1 - Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin
1 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
1 - Cyana Nachtgleves Münze
1 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
1 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
1 - Gul'dans Münze
1 - Helyas Münze
1 - Illidans Münze
1 - Kodas Siegel
1 - Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze
1 - Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze
1 - Lady Liadrins Münze
1 - Lunaras Münze
1 - Magistrix Elisandes Münze
1 - Nathanos Pestrufers Münze
1 - Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen
1 - Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld
1 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
1 - Remulos' Siegel
1 - Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze
1 - Stellagosas Silbermünze
1 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze

Alchemical Bonding Agent

4 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
4 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
3 - Gul'dans Münze
3 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
2 - Addie Zischmoors Münze
2 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
2 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
2 - Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel
2 - Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze
2 - Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen
2 - Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze
2 - Torok Bluttotems Münze
2 - Jaulons Mal
1 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
1 - Blingtrons Botmünze
1 - Havis Münze
1 - Helyas Münze
1 - König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze
1 - Lunaras Münze
1 - Murkys Münze
1 - Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara
1 - Remulos' Siegel
1 - Stellagosas Silbermünze
1 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze

Starfish on a String

7 - Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin
6 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze
5 - Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra
4 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
4 - Die Münze
3 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
3 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
3 - Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel
3 - Oculeths Verschwindemünze
3 - Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen
3 - Runas' letzte Kupfermünze
3 - Jaulons Mal
2 - Blingtrons Botmünze
2 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
2 - Cyana Nachtgleves Münze
2 - Falara Nachtweises Münze
2 - Gul'dans Münze
2 - König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze
2 - Murkys Münze
2 - Nathanos Pestrufers Münze
2 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
2 - Senegos' uralte Münze
2 - Stellagosas Silbermünze
2 - Vydhars Holzgroschen
1 - Addie Zischmoors Münze
1 - Berater Vandros' Münze
1 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
1 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
1 - Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur
1 - Havis Münze
1 - Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze
1 - Lunaras Münze
1 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
1 - Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig
1 - Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld
1 - Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze
1 - Torok Bluttotems Münze
1 - Tyrandes Münze

Tiny Little Grabbing Apparatus

7 - Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze
5 - Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra
5 - Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze
5 - Vydhars Holzgroschen
4 - Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie
4 - Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen
4 - Die Münze
3 - Gul'dans Münze
3 - Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze
3 - Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis
3 - Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze
3 - Stellagosas Silbermünze
3 - Torok Bluttotems Münze
2 - Elothirs goldenes Blatt
2 - Havis Münze
2 - Izal Weißmonds Münze
2 - Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen
2 - Remulos' Siegel
2 - Tyrandes Münze
1 - Addie Zischmoors Münze
1 - Berater Vandros' Münze
1 - Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden
1 - Bummbumm von Brullows Münze
1 - Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres
1 - Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur
1 - Genn Graumähnes Münze
1 - Helyas Münze
1 - Jace Düsterwebers Münze
1 - Jarod Schattensangs Münze
1 - Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze
1 - König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze
1 - Kodas Siegel
1 - Li Lis Münze
1 - Oculeths Verschwindemünze
1 - Okuna Langhauers Dublone
1 - Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig
1 - Senegos' uralte Münze
1 - Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze
1 - Jaulons Mal

Kommentar von zombiemall

I started this adventure by turning on Alien (cable TV - so there were lots of commercials) and set to task working on Der Wunschentferner in the Battle for Azeroth expansion, 3 days prior to the release of 8.2.

It appears that the coin, Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara is the rarest to get and has the drop equivalent of Old Ironjaw Alter Eisenkiefer and Old Crafty Alter Fuchs.

Evidence shows that using Seestern mit Faden is one such item that helps with fishing up the Queen's Royal Seal, plus you have the chance of fishing up 2 coins at once.

I used Fishing Buddy to help keep track of my cast counts. I used all of the other items that Marcia Balzer sells until I was down to two final coins needed.
I started using the starfish at around cast # 1250.

At cast 1408 I fished up Berater Vandros' Münze.

At cast 1527 Ripley blew the alien out of the airlock.

At cast 1541 Aliens started (same channel).

At cast 1684, just as they were coming out of hypersleep, I fished up Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara using the Seestern mit Faden and finally completed Der Wunschentferner.

Your mileage may vary based on the RNG of the drop, but just pop in a fun movie and let time fly. It'll be over before you know it.
Well.. have a sequel or another movie ready.

Kommentar von Dannell

Thanks to all of the people logging their catches!

I fished for an hour and got most of them before I started getting lots of dups. So I came here (thanks in particular to DrRobosnarfen, Esinar, and Spoonzilla) and discovered the lures to use. Fished another hour and a bit and got everything but Gallywix' Coin on a String, so I bought three each of Micro-Vortex Generator, Tiny Little Grabbing Apparatus,and Hypermagnetic Lure (only one at a time, of course; they're unique). Fished with my Dragon Fishing Pole until they were gone and no Gallywix coin, although I did pull in two (yes, two!) Giant Sewer Rats and half a dozen carp). Bought two more of each thing, then fell into the fountain, ruining my lovely G.E.A.R Commander outfit (do you have any idea how long it takes to dry that out?). Climbed out and fished some more; no luck. Gallywix must've pulled the string...

I suppose I can go another hour... The next day, three casts with the Hypermagnetic Lure and there it was... I win! ;-)

Kommentar von laydbird

Adding some more data into the pool. Did this today, and it took 863 casts (technically 865, but two of them were too far over and caught Sewer Carp, which doesn't have the chance for a coin).

Addie Fizzlebog's Coin - 2
Advisor Vandros' Coin - 4
Allari the Souleater's Coin - 6
Altruis the Sufferer's Coin - 3
Blingtron's Botcoin - 1
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin - 8
Coin of Golk the Rumble - 7
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin - 3
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin - 5
Elothir's Golden Leaf - 3
Falara Nightsong's Coin - 5
First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin - 6
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String - 4
Genn Greymane's Coin - 6
God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin - 8
Gul'dan's Coin - 8
Havi's Coin - 5
Helya's Coin - 3
Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet - 6
Illidan's Coin - 4
Izal Whitemoon's Coin - 7
Jace Darkweaver's Coin - 7
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin - 2
Kayn Sunfury's Coin - 4
King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin - 2
Koda's Sigil - 9
Korvas Bloodthorn's Coin - 9
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin - 1 (my last one!)
Lady Liadrin's Coin - 2
Li Li's Coin - 6
Lunara's Coin - 2
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest - 8
Magistrix Elisande's Coin - 5
Malfurion's Coin - 3
Murky's Coin - 6
Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin - 5
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin - 13
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon - 7
Ooker's Dookat - 6
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin - 7
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance - 5
Prince Farondis' Royal Seal - 4
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal - 5
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin - 2
Remulos' Sigil - 10
Runas' Last Copper - 7
Senegos' Ancient Coin - 2
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin - 6
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin - 4
Stellagosa's Silver Coin - 4
The Candleking's Candelcoin - 7
The Coin - 10
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin - 6
Tyrande's Coin - 1
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel - 8
Yowlon's Mark -7

Kommentar von Crowfiend

Just how many coins on a string does Gallywix have? If you didn't get your wish after the 11th coin maybe it's time to stop trying to cheat the fountain. God this never ends.

Kommentar von Dariuswow

Perhaps if I complain in a comment on Wowhead about trying to fish out Stellagosa’s Silver Coin for the last 4 hours it will boost my luck -_-

Edit: Aaaaand fished out 5 minutes later. Thanks Wowhead! :D

Kommentar von white86angel

After few years, I came back to finish this achievement. I left with Malfurions Münze and Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze

So Here are the stats,
4x Hypermagnetischer Köder, Auriphage Sardine, Klecks echt klebrigen Leims, & Mikrovortexgenerator
3x Wunschkristall, Alchemistisches Haftmittel, Seestern mit Faden, & Winzig kleines Greifgerät
are used

Stellagosas Silbermünze - 1
Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis - 3
Runas' letzte Kupfermünze - 5
Senegos' uralte Münze - 3
Okuna Langhauers Dublone - 0
Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen - 5
Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres - 4
Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie - 6
Tyrandes Münze - 2
Malfurions Münze - 1
Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze - 1
Jarod Schattensangs Münze - 2
Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld - 6
Remulos' Siegel - 4
Elothirs goldenes Blatt - 9
Kodas Siegel - 7
König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze - 3
Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel - 1
Murkys Münze - 5
Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze - 4
Addie Zischmoors Münze - 3
Bummbumm von Brullows Münze - 4
Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze - 7
Torok Bluttotems Münze - 6
Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze - 4
Genn Graumähnes Münze - 5
Nathanos Pestrufers Münze - 6
Helyas Münze - 6
Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze - 9
Havis Münze - 5
Vydhars Holzgroschen - 12
Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze - 8
Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra - 7
Magistrix Elisandes Münze - 2
Oculeths Verschwindemünze - 5
Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen - 5
Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig - 6
Berater Vandros' Münze - 1
Gul'dans Münze - 4
Jaulons Mal - 6
Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin - 2
Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden - 6
Cyana Nachtgleves Münze - 1
Falara Nachtweises Münze - 8
Izal Weißmonds Münze - 4
Jace Düsterwebers Münze - 2
Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze - 3
Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze - 2
Die Münze - 3
Blingtrons Botmünze - 7
Lady Liadrins Münze - 1
Lunaras Münze - 2
Illidans Münze - 7
Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara - 2
Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur - 2
Li Lis Münze - 5

That's almost all, Almost 2 Hours, i got my last one and almost obtain everything else except Okuna Langhauers Dublone.

Good Luck, Everyone who still doing it.

Kommentar von Ndnwow

I completed this with 6 of each lure for a total casting time of roughly 75 minutes. I had 567 casts and found all coins. The last 3 were Remulous' Sigil, Helya's Coin, and Malfurion's Coin. Best of luck!

Kommentar von akirajumps

My guide for Der Wunschentferner achievement:

1. Buy all of the lures when you first start, for a couple reasons:

- Lures are Unique so you can only hold one at a time, so this maximizes your time without having to stop fishing to buy more
- Some lures have a higher chance of catching items

If you are on a tight budget, you should prioritize the Hypermagnetischer Köder as this catches the most coins. After that:

Alchemistisches Haftmittel (Especially for Lunaras Münze)
Klecks echt klebrigen Leims (Especially for König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze)
Wunschkristall (Especially for Senegos' uralte Münze)
Mikrovortexgenerator (Just my personal suspicion, I like this one)

2. Buy a few Übergroßer Schwimmer. The larger bobber makes clicking faster/easier.

3. Create a /cast Fishing macro and bind it to a key that's easy to reach. (I bound mine to my '2' on my secondary cast bar)

4. Post up on the left side of Marcia Balzer and fish towards the right side of the Dalaran fountain. This increases the chances of your lure hitting fishable water while keeping your lure vendor close enough to click on without moving between casts.

Keep your lures up! Otherwise you will be catching a lot of Großer Brunnengoldfisch and not a lot of coins. My not-coin count was so high because I didn't keep the lures up all the time.

Like with the WotLK Dalaran Fountain, 'Gold' coins drop least often, followed by 'Silver', then 'Copper', then the miscellaneous coins:
I'll not bore you with my exact catch details, but here are the drop rates I experienced while fishing (Almost exactly 2 1/2 hours for full achievement):

32x 'Gold' Coins
46x 'Silver' Coins
65x 'Copper' Coins
78x Miscellaneous Coins
6x Kanalisationskarpfen
1x Magiesauger
551x Großer Brunnengoldfisch
1x Crystal Vial
1x Other Trash

Please give some upvotes to the users whose comments I utilized for this guide:

Haeven on the Lunaras Münze page
Haeven on the Senegos' uralte Münze page
Haeven on the König Mrgl-Mrgls Münze page
Melandroso on the Hypermagnetischer Köder page

If you're having difficulty with any specific coin, Haeven's comments are amazing, so look for them in the comment sections!
Good luck and happy fishing!

Kommentar von TheBigDeeb

i used more than 20+ Mikrovortexgenerator to catch Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara realm time 10:25 PM EU

Kommentar von Kamonas

1527 total casts.

I got 1264 Großer Brunnengoldfisch.
My last coin was the Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara.

Kommentar von schnizol

Not as bad as expected but Lady Liadrin's coin could be a little less rare >.<

Kommentar von Dimun

I have got it on 20 level with "Die Mittlerangel" with Aquadynamischer Fischanlocker and Kapitän Rumseys Lagerbier.
The last one Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara had been gotten.

Kommentar von vulpesveritas

I've not seen this mentioned in any of the other comments, so I thought I should say something. You can find coins for both this achievement and Der Münzmeister achievement in Broken Isles Dalaran by using the Fischfinderbrille. However, even if you find the gold coins from Northrend Dalaran in Broken Isles Dalaran, you cannot use them in the Broken Isles Dalaran fountain. Basically -- the gold coins are only useable in "Old Dal" (no matter where you find them) so you can't get the Glückstag bonus from them and hope it helps with this achievement.

Kommentar von Tyrsenus

I can't believe nobody pointed out the pattern in how the coins are ordered in the achievement. Each group of four coins is categorized:

Aszuna NPCs x4
Val'Sharah NPCs x4
Highmountain NPCs x4
Stormheim NPCs x4
Suramar NPCs x4
Demon Hunters x4
NPCs that don't appear in Broken Isles / Miscellaneous x4

It then repeats and follows the exact same pattern with the second half of the list.

The only ones that don't quite fit are Liadrin and Illidan under Miscellaneous (although Liadrin didn't appear in the Broken Isles at launch, and I guess technically Illidan wasn't alive at launch either?), but it's otherwise 100% consistent. I did a little analysis, but as far as I can tell there's no correlation between these groupings and the lures. But maybe it's more complex than that?

Aszuna:

Stellagosa's Silver Coin
Runas' Last Copper
Okuna Longtusk's Doubloon
Coin of Golk the Rumble

Val'Sharah:

Tyrande's Coin
Kur'talos Ravencrest's Spectral Coin
Penelope Heathrow's Allowance
Elothir's Golden Leaf

Highmountain:

King Mrgl-Mrgl's Coin
Murky's Coin
Addie Fizzlebog's Coin
The Candleking's Candelcoin

Stormheim:

God-King Skovald's Fel-Tainted Coin
Nathanos Blightcaller's Coin
Sir Finley Mrrgglton's Coin
Vydhar's Wooden Nickel

Suramar:

First Arcanist Thalyssra's Coin
Oculeth's Vanishing Coin
Pearlhunter Phin's Soggy Coin
Gul'dan's Coin

Demon hunters:

Allari the Souleater's Coin
Cyana Nightglaive's Coin
Izal Whitemoon's Coin
Kayn Sunfury's Coin

Miscellaneous:

The Coin
Lady Liadrin's Coin
Illidan's Coin
Gallywix's Coin-on-a-String

Azsuna:

Prince Farondis' Royal Seal
Senegos' Ancient Coin
Ooker's Dookat
Daglop's Infernal Copper Coin

Val'shara:

Malfurion's Coin
Jarod Shadowsong's Coin
Remulos' Sigil
Koda's Sigil

Highmountain:

Hemet Nesingwary's Bullet
Spiritwalker Ebonhorn's Coin
Boomboom Brullingsworth's Coin
Torok Bloodtotem's Coin

Stormheim:

Genn Greymane's Coin
Helya's Coin
Havi's Coin
Rax Sixtrigger's Gold-Painted Copper Coin

Suramar:

Magistrix Elisande's Coin
Ly'leth Lunastre's Family Crest
Advisor Vandros' Coin
Yowlon's Mark

Demon hunter:

Altruis the Sufferer's Coin
Falara Nightsong's Coin
Jace Darkweaver's Coin
Korvas Bloodthorn's Coin

Miscellaneous

Blingtron's Botcoin
Lunara's Coin
Queen Azshara's Royal Seal
Li Li's Coin

Kommentar von Bunmeister

Just finished this today finally, after well over a 1000 casts.

Lures don't seem to matter, for coin/type as long as you have the buff you'll be getting coins.
The only real difference was the 'Starfish On A String' As it was giving me 2x coins occasionally.

When you get sick of it...... Keep casting!

When you think RNG is laughing at you..... Keep casting!

When you think all hope is lost..... Keep casting!

They will drop my fishy friends......eventually.

Kommentar von thebl4ckd0g

I've been playing the game for so long and I never realized you could get the lures from the NPC. Came here to WoWhead today to check out notes once I found them on the NPC - and managed to cut down what I needed from 9 to 4 within 10 mins. time. :)

Kommentar von KitsuKe

I'm up to around 2k casts, the last thousand has been me looking for Jarod Shadowsong's Coin, i'm now trying the last desperate attempt of commenting here hoping it will give me a bout of good luck after such an unlikely series of unluck.

EDIT : Finally got it after 3 more hours of fishing on the next day, My luck is abysmal but i am glad to not have to fish in that pond ever again (until i do the WoTLK one)

Links

Der Wunschentferner

Fischt alle unten aufgelisteten Münzen aus dem Brunnen von Dalaran auf den Verheerten Inseln.

Kriterien

	Stellagosas Silbermünze (1)
	Runas' letzte Kupfermünze (1)
	Okuna Langhauers Dublone (1)
	Münze von Golk, dem Grollen des Meeres (1)
	Tyrandes Münze (1)
	Kur'talos Rabenkrones geisterhafte Münze (1)
	Penelope Heathrows Taschengeld (1)
	Elothirs goldenes Blatt (1)
	Königin Mrgl-Mrgls Münze (1)
	Murkys Münze (1)
	Addie Zischmoors Münze (1)
	Des Kerzenkönigs Kerzenmünze (1)
	Gottkönig Skovalds teufelsbesudelte Münze (1)
	Nathanos Pestrufers Münze (1)
	Sir Finley Mrrggltons Münze (1)
	Vydhars Holzgroschen (1)
	Münze der Ersten Arkanistin Thalyssra (1)
	Oculeths Verschwindemünze (1)
	Perlenjäger Phins patschnasser Pfennig (1)
	Gul'dans Münze (1)
	Münze von Allari der Seelenfresserin (1)
	Cyana Nachtgleves Münze (1)
	Izal Weißmonds Münze (1)
	Kayn Sonnenzorns Münze (1)
	Die Münze (1)
	Lady Liadrins Münze (1)
	Illidans Münze (1)
	Gallywix' Münze an der Schnur (1)

	Königliches Siegel von Prinz Farondis (1)
	Senegos' uralte Münze (1)
	Des Knatzelfiddlers Flotschgroschen (1)
	Kupfermünze von Daglops Höllenbestie (1)
	Malfurions Münze (1)
	Jarod Schattensangs Münze (1)
	Remulos' Siegel (1)
	Kodas Siegel (1)
	Hemet Nesingwarys Kugel (1)
	Geistwandler Ebenhorns Münze (1)
	Bummbumm von Brullows Münze (1)
	Torok Bluttotems Münze (1)
	Genn Graumähnes Münze (1)
	Helyas Münze (1)
	Havis Münze (1)
	Rax Sechszünders goldbemalte Kupfermünze (1)
	Magistrix Elisandes Münze (1)
	Ly'leth Lunastres Familienwappen (1)
	Berater Vandros' Münze (1)
	Jaulons Mal (1)
	Münze von Altruis dem Leidenden (1)
	Falara Nachtweises Münze (1)
	Jace Düsterwebers Münze (1)
	Kor'vas Blutdorns Münze (1)
	Blingtrons Botmünze (1)
	Lunaras Münze (1)
	Königliches Siegel von Königin Azshara (1)
	Li Lis Münze (1)

Guides

Legion Fishing Guide

Der Wunschentferner

Kriterien

Guides

Weiteres

Beitragen